Love Island All Stars has faced controversy as fans accuse producers of intentionally excluding key contestants from on-screen action. Fans have expressed frustration over the minimal appearance of popular couples Scott van-der-Sluis and Leanne Amaning, who were paired early in the series but have barely been shown on TV. Viewers took to social media, particularly X (formerly Twitter), to demand more screen time for the duo, with some joking about putting them on a 'milk carton.' The issue has sparked accusations that producers are deliberately sidelining certain contestants to influence the show's narrative, especially as some couples, like Scott and Leanne, are perceived to be unfairly marginalized. Additionally, fans questioned the absence of narrator Iain Stirling during episodes, suggesting a lack of content to narrate, and speculated about the potential return of popular star Curtis Pritchard, which has been kept under wraps. The show's format includes surprise evictions and public votes, with recent episodes revealing a shock double eviction and a forthcoming first public vote-based dump. The controversy over contestants' visibility continues as viewers suspect that the manipulation of screen time may be affecting the show's fairness and outcome.